36 years since the Guerin case | Musqueam Day 2020

November 1, 2020

Musqueam Day: Celebrating 36 since the Guerin case

Every year, Musqueam recognizes November 1 as Musqueam Day. This is a holiday to celebrate the Guerin case and landmark 1984 Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) decision that fundamentally changed Aboriginal law in Canada. Today and everyday, we acknowledge the strength and determination of our ancestors to seek justice. Read on to learn more about this important court case.

History of the Guerin case

In 1957, the Government of Canada leased 162 acres of Musqueam Reserve lands to the Shaughnessy Golf and Country Club for 75 years. This land, which was approximately one-third of the already-limited reserve lands, were leased for a fraction of its value. It is worth noting that, at the time, the federal government did not permit Status Indians to vote and had only granted the ability for Indians to hire lawyers or seek legal advice in 1951. Still, the Department of Indian Affairs’ Indian Agent denied Musqueam access to legal representation in this negotiation and the final lease was concealed from the band.

About 13 years later, in 1970, Chief Delbert Guerin was granted access to Department of Indian Affairs archives and became the first Musqueam person to review the signed lease. He discovered the terms of the official lease were not the same terms Musqueam had agreed to with the Indian Agent, and the band decided to sue the federal government. It took many years to find a lawyer that would take on the case, since there was no legal or government acknowledgement of Aboriginal rights. The case was finally filed in 1975.

Fighting for our land rights in court

Musqueam argued that the government has a responsibility to act in the best interest of Indigenous peoples, and by signing this lease they had not upheld that duty for the Musqueam peoples.

Musqueam won the first case in 1979, and was awarded $10 million before the Federal Court of Appeal overturned the decision, stating the federal government has a political obligation to Indigenous peoples, not legal. The case was taken to the Supreme Court of Canada, and on November 1, 1984, the highest court in Canada ruled in favour of the Musqueam Indian Band.

The SCC decision confirmed that the Crown’s Indian Agent misled Musqueam about the terms of the lease with Shaughnessy Golf Course, resulting in a lease with much less favourable terms for the First Nation. A court majority agreed that the nature of Aboriginal rights imposes an enforceable, pre-existing “fiduciary” responsibility upon the Crown – the government must act in the best interest of Indigenous peoples and uphold Aboriginal rights.

In the Guerin case, the inherent right to Aboriginal title, first recognized in the Royal Proclamation of 1763, was established as a sui generis land right. This means that land title is a unique, inherent, collective right to the use of and jurisdiction over traditional territories that is a result of ancestral occupation and relationship with our lands. Therefore, the Crown has a fiduciary responsibility to act in the best interest of an Indian Band in relation to its Indian reserve lands.

Impacts of the Guerin case

R v. Guerin is widely acknowledged as a landmark Supreme Court decision. It has been ranked among the most important SCC decisions of the 20^th century because it demonstrated that Indigenous peoples “could obtain a legal remedy of wrongs done to them by government” (J. I. Reynolds, p. 2).

In 2005, leaders and lawyers involved in Guerin v. The Queen [1984] were brought together for a panel discussion recognizing the 20^th anniversary of the case. James I. Reynolds, a lawyer who represented Musqueam, presented on his book A Breach of Duty: Fiduciary Obligations and Aboriginal Peoples (2005), which he wrote about the legal impacts of the Guerin case. Later, the presentation was published in Vancouver Bar Association’s The Advocate (read it online as a PDF).

Reynolds states that, at the time, “the widely held view was that the Crown could not be held liable in law for the way in which it managed reserve lands or other assets of the Indian bands.” The Guerin case was pivotal because it fundamentally changed Aboriginal law in relation to the:

legal enforceability of the Crown’s obligations to Aboriginal people;
fiduciary duty owed to Aboriginal people;
nature of Aboriginal title; and
duty to consult

This case is also acknowledged as changing the law relating to other fiduciary obligations owed to a range of vulnerable people.

Celebrating the Guerin case

November 1 is designated as Musqueam Day, a day to acknowledge the hard work that resulted in a victory for all Indigenous peoples in Canada. Musqueam Administration observes this day as a statutory holiday. All non-essential services are closed to enable staff to celebrate this historic ruling. This year, because November 1 is a Sunday, Musqueam Administration will be closed on November 2. The office will reopen on Tuesday, November 3.

We encourage all Musqueam community members to honour our ancestors by learning learn more about the case.